1105 New York Avenue, Cape May NJ - UNDER CONTRACT

For Sale: $3,200,000
MLS: 261127     Beds: 4     Baths: 3.1     Type: Single Family     Lot: 7501     Taxes: $10,472     DOM: 6 Days

Welcome to this classic Cape May home, built in 1914, completely renovated in 2013 for year-round living, and lovingly maintained by the same family for over 50 years. Just two blocks from the beach with off-street parking, this 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath gem sits in a prime location where you can enjoy the luxury of being mere steps to the sand and a short bike ride to the iconic Washington Street Mall, known for its premier shopping and dining. Located on one of the most desired residential streets in Cape May, you are greeted with an inviting, covered front porch with awnings and plenty of seating. Inside, the first floor features teak floors, an open concept layout with living and dining areas showcasing lots of natural light, plus a generously sized chef’s kitchen with a Viking range, attached pantry, and concealed full-size washer and dryer. French doors from the dining area open to a serene screened-in porch with a wrap-around deck behind. This floor is complete with a living space/den that acts as a 5th bedroom, with pocket doors and a full bath attached. The second floor features a primary suite, including a queen-sized bed with private bath, office for two, and covered porch looking out to the gorgeous backyard. The second and third bedrooms and another full bath make up the rest of the second floor, while the third floor boasts a fourth bedroom and half bath. The outdoor space shines with a lovely mahogany deck, refreshing outdoor shower, lush landscaping, and a beautifully maintained rear exterior where you can unwind after a day in the sun. A full basement plus a garden shed out back provide ample storage for bikes and all beach essentials. This historic seashore oasis blends Cape May tradition with the modern comforts you’ve been dreaming of. Schedule your showing today!

PROPERTY FEATURES & AMENITIES

Deck   Porch   Screened Porch   Grill   Storage Building   Sidewalks   Outside Shower   Living Room   Kitchen   Den/TV Room   Eat-In-Kitchen   Dining Area   Pantry   Laundry Closet   Range   Oven   Microwave Oven   Refrigerator   Washer   Dryer   Dishwasher   Disposal   Smoke/Fire Detector   Stove Natural Gas   Stainless steel appliance   Heat Fuel:Gas Natural   Water Heater:Gas- Natural   Water Heater:On Demand   Basement:Full,Outside Entrance,Inside Entrance   Stone Driveway   Fireplace- Gas   Wood Flooring   Smoke/Fire Alarm   Tile Flooring   Kitchen Island   Cooling:Central Air Condition   City   Two Story

PROPERTY MAP & AERIAL VIEW

Last Database Update: 08/15/2026 11:01:22

Request Property Information - 1105 New York Avenue, Cape May NJ 4 Bedroom(s)   |   3.1 Bathroom(s)   |    For Sale: $3,200,000   |   MLS Number: 261127   |   Property Type: Single Family Provided by: The Craig Soens Team - www.craigsoens.com (Information Above Will Appear At The Top Of The Email That Is Sent To The Craig Soens Team)

Let THE CRAIG SOENS TEAM be your buyer's agent for this listing.LISTING IS PROVIDED BY JERSEY CAPE REALTY. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web page appears in part through the Cape May County MLS program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms in which we participate, and is provided by Cape May County MLS through a licensing agreement. Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to change, withdrawal, or prior sale.